Joking aside, this was actually very difficult. Steven, it's only now I realise how correct you were when you said in the end you have to choose tracks for personal, subjective reasons, rather than trying to pick out the "best" lyrics and music.
Without further ado:
10. My Beautiful Reward. A simple, spiritual song. Live it is superior to the album.
(Incase anyone wants to see Bruce singing it live:)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AFbYf0D9nmE
9. Erie Canal. Had to include something from The Seeger Sessions. That concert must be one of the most mind blowing I have attended in recent years, and I can still recall the sensation of being completely awed by the sound from the band when they played this number in Birmingham. The music blended into a remarkably elevating sound, and I especially recall the brass instruments, but, really, the sum was greater than any of the parts. It so brings to life a vision of the Erie Canal back in its day, and I hear everything Bruce envisioned for this album, in this song. (The original was written, as it says in the notes, in 1905 by Thomas S Allen and called Low Bridge, Everybody Down.)
8. The Hitter. The sparse arrangement and Bruce's 'in-character' expressionless voice draws me right in to the feel of this song. I find it very sad. The story of a man's plea to the (probably once abusive) mother who never had time for him, a man who makes his living as a bare-knuckle boxer. He asks her only to open her door for a while for him to get some rest, but again, even this is denied him. And so again:
Tonight in the shipyard/ a man draws a circle in the dirt/ I move to the centre and I take off my shirt/ I study him for the cuts, the scars, the pain/ Man nor time can erase/ I move to the left and I strike to the face.
(Tom Jones does an excellent cover of The Hitter on his new album 24 Hours.)
7. Ghost of Tom Joad. Bruce apparently told his audiences to 'shut the f*ck up' on the GoTJ tour. I missed that tour cos he played small venues which meant tickets sold out in a nanosecond. He made everyone shut up, explaining that his songs were written with a lot of silence, and he needed silence to sing them in. I like that a lot.
The live version with Tom Morello including Morello's fantastic guitar solo recently released as part of the four track Magic Tour Highlights Release for Danny's Melanoma Fund is definitely my favourite version. Even though there's not much silence in it.
6. My City of Ruins. I had to include something from The Rising, could have been one of three or four songs, but I settled on My City of Ruins, because of the simplicity and call for action in the words,
with these hands . . . come on rise up.
The Rising Tour was the last time I saw Danny Federici, and when he died I had a mental image of the stage as it was, there at Crystal Palace in 2002, with a blank space where Danny had been standing. That concert was also the only Springsteen concert that a great friend of mine, who has since died, came along to with me. So this song, and this album, reminds me of loss, and of hope, which of course what Springsteen wrote it about.
5. For You. This one returns happy memories. The best lines:
And your strength is devastating in the face of all these odds/ Remember how I kept you waiting when it was my turn to be the god?
Better live than on the album.
4. Backstreets. Right from the marvellous Roy Bittan piano intro, this is a top track. Strangely, for many years I did not realise Terry could be a girl's name, so I must have misinterpreted the song for most of my life, but it has always reminded me of my young days and my oldest friends.
One soft infested summer me and Terry became friends/ Trying in vain to breathe the fire we was born in. The ungrammatical street-poeticness of it is part of the appeal.
There was nothing left to say but I hated him and I hated you when you went away. There is something about this line at the end of the of third verse - less to do with the words than the sound of the words and the way he sings them. Many other of the stand-out lines like this are emphasised by similar rhyming and repetition, like Lost in the the Flood and the line (repeating "oil" and rhyming "flood"),
man that ain't oil that's blood. Very satisfying line. So too somehow is
we shut 'em up and then we shut 'em down, from Racin in the Street. That line gets me every time. I don't even know what it means:-) -->
3. Racin' in the Street
Just a brilliant song, musically and lyrically. Even amongst those other gems of songs on Darkness it shines like a diamond. The action in Springsteen's songs is a large part of their appeal. The album original has to come first, but I also find the live version on Live 75- 85 to be pretty excellent.
2.5 Blood Brothers
Marvellous track about how we get through this thing together.
And it's a ride, ride, ride, and there ain't much cover/ With no one runnin' by your side, my blood brother.
2. The River
The River was my first BS album, and this song was the first of Springsteen's that I got to know and love. Simple and devastating lyrics. The words are much enhanced by the melancholy feel of the music. Too many excellent versions to choose between.
1.5 Born to Run
It was ringing in my ears as I returned home on the back of my then boyfriend's motorbike after my first Springsteen and E Street concert in 1985.
(A less-quoted line from this song,
Wendy, let me in, I wanna be your friend, I wanna guard your dreams and visions reminds me of a definition of love I was recently stunned to hear, which is that love is being the guardian of each other's solitude.)
1. Badlands
Lyrically brilliant, and also the ultimate, singalong, dancealong track. I enjoy every nuance of the piano and drums and guitars. A highlight of every concert, with the extended last chorus. Perfection on steroids.
It ain't no sin to be glad you're alive.
I was attempting to ascertain the meaning of the lyrics. -- Spock
It's a song, you green-blooded Vulcan. You don't analyse it. The point is you have a good time singing it. -- McCoy
Phew. I will think twice next time I suggest "listing" something:-) . But I am helpless to prevent myself veering off on these Bruce trips every once in a while. It's a lonely compulsion, but what can I do? Nice to be able to write here. Looking forward much to reading others' top tens. It would be good if more people than just us usual suspects joined in, too, but I'll not hold my breath on that one.
Cheers,
Diane