MarieM wrote: ↑Thu Oct 12, 2023 12:54 amI value Leonard's archives because he did. He felt they had value that exceeded what was published. What we have are the gems. What we are missing is how they were polished and how many were discarded. The interest, I suppose, is mostly scholarly. but I would love to see the process whereby Leonard produced some of his greatest lines. To see how he might have come from a dark place into the light with some of his songs would be inspiring. The opportunity to understand the life of a genius doesn't come up that often...LisaLCFan wrote: ↑Tue Oct 10, 2023 9:32 pm ...perhaps this is just my perception, but it seems like a bit too much emphasis is being placed on the supposed importance of the contents of Leonard's archives -- are the personal, rough and/or unfinished bits and pieces of his life really essential to keeping his songs alive, as has been suggested?
Thank you, Marie, for your very thoughtful response. I actually do agree with what you wrote -- it would, indeed, be fascinating to be able to see the genesis and evolution of Leonard's work in his many notebooks, and I did not mean to suggest that they have no value. Rather, I was merely thinking that the archives are separate from Leonard's body of published work, insofar as nothing can diminish the brilliance of those published works, or diminish the appreciation of them, or diminish the impact that they have had, and will continue to have, on people's lives. Of course, if the archives eventually become available for people to examine, then that could certainly serve to enhance people's appreciation and understanding of Leonard's published works, but regardless of whatever may happen, nothing can take away from those works.
I suppose I just wanted to point out how fortunate we are to have everything that Leonard gave us during his lifetime, and that these current legal problems should not be seen in any way to be tarnishing those gems. It never hurts to shine some light on something beautiful and positive that we already have, and that we will always have, perhaps in spite of whatever darkness and negativity may be happening in other corners.
Cheers, and thanks again for taking the time to write these posts.